Keepers of the Crown

1977-Joy Sato

1978-KarenHawes

1979-Karen Boback

1980-Carol New Martineaux

1981-Penny Schalch

1982-Hannah Robzen

1983-Judy Daddona

1984-Catherine Byrnes

1985-Mary Powell

1986-Jane Ann Lessig

1987-Mary Beth Leonard

1988-Stephani Coiffi

1989-Maureen Sherman

1990-Theresa Rosa-Nuzzo

1991-Theresa McDonald

1992-Doris Dalton (Mrs. America 1992)

1993- Michele Benton

1994- Maria Gaygan

1995- Patricia Moseley

1996- Tracey Mazeroski 

1997- Mercedes Cipolloni 

1998- Terri Begg

1999- Stephanie Dawn Lemma

2000--Molly Ray Callaghan

2001--Lori Sundberg

2002--Ana Enriquetta

2004--Angela Evans

2005--Kandace Gary

2006--Jill Snyder

2007--Allison Marie Dalcamo

2008--Shelley Bortz Ligashesky

2009--Joyelle Scavone (Top 10 Finalist)

2010--Summer Wise

2011--Erin Joy Landis

2012--Susan Huntley

2013--Andrea Graham

2014--Amira Hamid

2015--Kate Schartel Novak

2016--April Walker Taylor